I think it looks great but I'm a bit confused!
I feed my dog Tribal TLC alongside Butternut Box. Tribal was previously rated at 4.5 (90%) but has dropped significantly to 73%.
I do realise from what David has said that some foods have had their ratings dropped but I'm puzzled by this when other cold pressed foods that use meat meal rather than fresh meat as Tribal does are scoring so highly in comparison (20% higher in some cases).
Also, having a browse through the product pages I've come across, as an example, Arden Grange Prestige which is extruded, has a red ingredient (maize) and a low meat content according to the symbols.
Also Natural Dog Food Company Turkey Light which is extruded, has rice as its main ingredient and low meat content.
Yet both rate exactly the same as Tribal under the new rating algorithm.
Paul O'Grady's Hypoallergenic actually rates higher at 75%, yet is extruded, has low meat content and rice as its first ingredient.
I appreciate that David does an amazing job and this must have been a huge undertaking so I don't wish to sound critical, I am just genuinely puzzled and unsure if I'm missing something with these ratings?